I agree with you. I was just making the other sides argument.
. Also, because I see so many of the cards that are only cleaned it is a little worrisome they will wear red hats when many of them shouldn't be.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Peter_Spaeth
It isn't wrong to do it per se. if in fact PSA would reject it if it knew that had been done, and I guess that's how I would read their standards, then technically it's wrong not to disclose it when you sell the card. Now that said, some violations are less offensive than others, it's like driving 56 versus driving 90 in a 55 MPH zone. Imperfect world, there are always slippery slope arguments like you're making, and one can almost always identify a case where a law or rule doesn't make sense, but you have to be practical.
Anyhow, there are obviously major things being done to these cards that the vast majority of the hobby would deem unacceptable. Therefore, it's fraud not to disclose them. The fact that there is no perfect consensus in the hobby is a red herring. Intentional misrepresentation or concealment of a material fact. Fraud 101.
|