Hi Scott, I was/am a big Mantle collector and had much of his oddball stuff (was #4 on Mantle Master Registry). I had a 53 Stahl PSA 1MK with a bunch of creases in the corners, and some staining along with a black stamp. I paid $1300 for it back in 2016... honestly I’d say a raw beat up 53 Stahl would be under $1k... if graded then a bit over $1k assuming the condition. They are almost all pretty beat up, but it is the easiest to find of the Stahls and I do think the lesser conditioned Mantle non mainstream cards have cooled off a bit the past couple of years. There were a couple of big collectors going for the Mantle Master registry that have accumulated the Carr’s they needed and really pushed the market up on PSA graded oddball items.
|