Quote:
Originally Posted by Jobu
I was discussing my recent post about my 1902-1903 team photo from Matty McIntyre's personal album with a few friends (hi Steve and Val), when it became clear that Bill Carrick's E107 is wrong.
...I found the following 1902 Carl Horner piece which labels the E107 player as Carrick and could be the source of the confusion.
|
The players in the Horner composites had sat for their photos in the Horner studio in Boston, so it would be surprising if someone were misidentified. I am not aware of anyone else in a Horner composite being misnamed.
He is player #5 in the Spalding composite below. The face of player #5 resembles the face in the newspaper illustration that I've also attached, and I think both match the Horner photo.