Quote:
Originally Posted by btcarfagno
When I look at Edgar Martinez stats, I see someone who, if he had been a shitty fielder, would likely deserve to be in the Hall Of Fame. My problem with potentially voting for him, however, is that, had he been forced to play in the field as well as hit over the years, his offensive stats would likely not have been as good as they were. Are his offensive stats so good that a bit of a dip in them would retain their Hall Of Fame worthiness? I'm not so sure.
|
Agreed. Also Coors field aside, how can you put Edgar in without Larry Walker? Walker had almost identical numbers + an MVP and 7 gold gloves.