Quote:
Originally Posted by bravos4evr
I don't like this argument. What constitutes an era? If we just look at who the top 3 at any given position are without comparing them to the rest of history at said position we are just going to weaken the HOF more than it is already.
Was the player in the top 10-15 all time at their position?
If not were they in the top 10 in the game at any position during their career?
Does that players stats paint a picture of an all time great? Or just a good player who played a position that had poor depth league wide at the time?
|
Some of the players you say no to I think pass your litmus test.