For my HOF collection, I have tried to obtain a different card for each HOFer, even though I have several cards with multiple HOFers on them. This way, I have the same number of cards as inductees. I would consider your card good for any of the three players (although, calling it my "Clarke" card would probably be my first option). Nice card, and happy collecting!
My HOF collection:
http://s155.photobucket.com/user/tri...?sort=6&page=1