Quote:
Originally Posted by rats60
What about none of the above? I don't agree with any of your choices. I think Wagner is a lot more than red Cobb, more in line with green Cobb. I think Plank is equal to none of the players you listed, but in between like Speaker is less than Cobb, but more than lesser hofers.
|
You raise fair points. Perhaps the way I went about this was a bit too basic.
It is too late to change it now unfortunately, and pathetically this thread was already my second attempt at getting a proper poll going. If I start a new thread or poll on this forum they may well kick me off
Maybe tiers similar to the below would work better? ...
Wagner = Cobb (green)
Wagner = Cobb (red)
Wagner = Young, Matty, Johnson
Wagner = Lajoie, Speaker
Plank = Young, Matty, Johnson
Plank = Lajoie, Speaker
Plank = Brown, Bender, Waddell, Joss, Walsh, Marquard etc.
Anything to add? I do appreciate ideas which may improve the discussion.
I am very curious to hear the communities thoughts on how they value the iconic duo of Wagner & Plank and I look forward to hearing more thoughts on this subject.
Thank you truly to everyone for their input.
Derek