Absolutely anything can be returned if bought on eBay even if it is described adequately. Despite his sales tactics he is selling exactly what he is advertising--and SGC Auth Orr rookie so there should not be grounds for a return.
As far as his claims about size goes, that is not relevant. Many issues come smaller so you have to look at other attributes to determine if a card has been trimmed. Based on his scan the top edge at a minimum looks suspect. Hard to be sure without having it in hand.
|