[Sidepocket]

I would love to know your thoughts about PSA grading and their all too common reject of "min size". I posted this on the PSA board but of course it's their site and everyone has to be careful about criticizing PSA, so I'm hoping to get more insight here.

I cracked out these cards (along with several others) and subbed them hoping for some bumps. Instead I got what you see below. Five previously graded cards all rejected for size (well, one was for altered stock). How can this happen? Lack of quality control? Is the grading game rigged? Comments and advice would be appreciated.

BTW, I emailed them a week ago and have heard nothing. I also received nothing from them with regards to refunding my grading fees either by voucher or some other method. Very disappointing.

Before and after pics:






Don't have a "before" scan of this but it was a PSA 6: