I don't think Aaron cards are undervalued; Mantle cards are overvalued. He benefits from being white and a Yankee during the Stengel era.
Williams' cards are little tougher to evaluate against the others, for two reasons:
1. His rookie cards were prewar and cannot really be compared with Topps and Bowman RCs in terms of availability, quality, etc.; and
2. He had an inordinate number of #1 (and last card in the set in 1954T) cards in the postwar era: 1954T, 1957T, 1958T. Mays had one that I can think of (1966), I don't think Mantle had any, and Aaron had 1 (1974).
Last edited by Exhibitman; 09-14-2015 at 08:46 AM.
|