Deron - I've never owned a DiMaggio, but I do have the Babe.
Your scans strain my old eyes but I am concerned about how uniform the rounded corners appear...doesn't look natural
The background on the Ruth looks a little shiny too.
I am no expert, these are just my opinions.
Here is my Babe so you can see one that I'm fairly sure is authentic:
BABE RUTH 1948 Leaf-3 PSA-5.jpg
Hope this helps you.
I always try to get graded cards if I'm getting high-dollar cards.
Good Luck,
Raymond
.
.