[robw1959]

I'm admittedly not too savvy about this issue. A few years ago, I bought a PSA 3 Goudey Ruth card that I thought was a reprint because it was a "Buy-It-Now" deal for only $1000. I even cracked it out and sent it to PSA for authentication, and they promptly reholdered it in a PSA 3 slab for me.

I recently picked up these two cards on the Bay. They do have that Goudey thickness, but they just feel too smooth on either side, if you know what I mean. Plus neither have any discernible traces of that Goudey ghosting so commonly found on the backs. What do you think, guys?