Yes, it measures up-- Rick P. doesn't really do write ups for any listing, which I rather like as it lets the collectors' eyes do all the work.
I will say that the handful of raw cards I have up there I had every intention of slabbing at some point, and chose them as carefully as I choose the graded ones. I just decided to sell this batch for a coming purchase before getting around to grading them. I never submitted any of my raw card listed there-- so they were not submitted and rejected, and then listed, just to be very clear on those examples. Tangentially, I especially loved that 54 Ted Williams for its centering
