I hate to answer such a long question with such a short answer, but I don't grade cards for my collection. It isn't so much that I think the grading system for Old Judges is seriously flawed (it is, but that's not my primary reason), it's that I have a lot of cards and grading them all would be a waste of money and it would be too bulky. Having said that, to sell cards you need to have them graded. Therefore, if I had some Old Judges to sell I would probably grade them. To maximize the price I would probably choose PSA. Again, this has nothing to do with the quality of the grading or the holders (I think SGC is better on both counts). It's just that for some reason PSA cards realize more.
|