[vthobby]

Yes to MK but no on MC.

Here is another big problem. Sometimes when you see MK, it is tough to actually find the MK on the card. Stamps and writing are obvious but I've seen MK designated and spent some time looking.

There should be a factor within the MK as to severity. This PSA 4 has SEVERE MK and I think it is blatantly obvious. If this card had a slight roller mark or someone's initials on the back then those should also be weighed based on "eye appeal".

I stand by my initial point. This is not a 4 by any standards. It is a 2 or a 3 on the best of days, maybe even a 1? It looks like someone took a piece of charcoal and smeared the front of the card.

Peace, Mike