I think you guys are sort of on track with your value estimates. I wish I could get an auction house to open bidding at $2,500 on one of my cards that I value at $4K. More typical would be $1K or so. $4K might be a tad bit high as Deacon was a newly elected HOF'er when Rob's was auctioned off and not only Old Judge pose collectors but also HOF RC collectors would have aggressively been looking for that card at that time. Since then, some HOF RC collectors likely would have picked up an example by now.
Last edited by bcbgcbrcb; 03-01-2015 at 12:11 AM.
|