Quote:
	
	
		| 
					Originally Posted by yanks12025  Where is there a agreement that the Jennings is good??? | 
	
 The Jennings looks good to me.
Another possibility is that all the autographs are good except Cobb, and that Cobb was added as a 'clubhouse' (I hate that term) because he was the most famous player on the team, and 'needed' to be on the bat.  The clubhouse signatures I've seen from the '40s-'60s are so bad that if this is a clubhouse, being much earlier than '40s-'60s, it's a damned good one (I would expect it to be equally horrible as compared to more modern ones).  Keeping in mind that forgeries are normally a lot better than clubhouse.
Just thinking out loud.  I would love to see this item be totally authentic, which probably colors my thinking.