George Raft
Derek Carr
Refrigerator Perry
Tom House
Because I personally lack any sense of reality , I veered off the question...I think OP was trying to get us to choose a cherished cardboard piece to keep us occupied on the island.
I'd like to have the 1971 Topps FB set so I could memorize each player, each of their stats and the witty Topps Bios on the back.
Oh wait, I already did that
Ok, give me one of my 1927 York Caramel E210-2 Lou Gehrig cards. I won't need both if I am on a deserted island , that would be crazy.