Quote:
Originally Posted by Mountaineer1999
Wow! This is an awful lot of words about Adam Dunn, a guy I would have never put in the same sentence with HOF.
|
In fairness, I think the thread stopped being about Dunn awhile back. Now it's more of a Reggie Jackson/what makes a Hall of Famer? thread.
My 2 cents, Jackson was a Hall of Famer. Not a top tier all time great. But if it's the Hall of FAME, then Reggie certainly qualifies. One of those guys that you wouldn't take a bathroom break when he was coming up to bat. Of course, there are quite a few other guys that you could say the same thing about (Canseco in his prime, McGwire, Joey Belle, etc), but they we're either PED guys, dicks, had too short of a prime, or all of the above...