View Single Post
  #3  
Old 08-12-2014, 02:38 PM
btcarfagno btcarfagno is offline
T0m C@rf@gn0
Member
 
Join Date: May 2010
Location: Central New Jersey
Posts: 3,284
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by honus94566 View Post
OK, ignore the thread title. I am sure it is more than worth it.

But, I do have a question, and am hoping for some advice from you northeasterners that are more familiar with the area than I am.

Here's my situation: I am from the western US, my wife really wants to visit NYC because she has never been. We have 3 kids and are pretty busy, so this is a rare escape for us, just my wife and I are going (the kids are staying at Grandma's).

We'll be landing in NYC late Wed night, and will be there until sunday evening. So we have basically 4 complete days. We are staying in Manhattan so we weren't planning on renting a car or anything, just doing things around there. She wants to see the sights, go to a broadway musical, restaurants, shopping, etc. Typical tourist stuff, nothing more than a short vacation with nothing specific really planned yet.

We are going at the end of september - perfect fall weather in the northeast, and I am sure perfect around cooperstown. So I am thinking it would be great if we could get out of the city for just 1 of the days and go to the hall of fame. She's a baseball fan too and would enjoy it, she knows quite a bit about cards, has read baseball books like the glory of our times, so I am sure she would enjoy the trip and not think of it as ruining a day of our vacation or anything.

But my question is, is this even plausible? for a day drip, somehow finding our way out of manhattan on public transit, renting a car in NJ or something, and driving out there? Am I nuts or can this be done? We have booked our flight but no hotels yet, so I guess there is always the option of staying one night somewhere, and coming back to NYC the next day. I dunno. Just kind of thinking out loud here.

If you were on vacation for 4 days in NYC would you see cooperstown as a viable side trip, or is it just too far away and complicated to get to? If so, how would you get there (take what transit out of the city, rent a car where, etc).

Oh, forgot to mention this, as it's probably relevant... It would probably be Saturday that we would go, as I am thinking the traffic/transit might be easier to navigate if it is not a weekday.

Thanks for any suggestions!
It depends.

How much "stuff" do the two of you want to do in NY? The trip to Cooperstown and back will be an all day affair. There is plenty to do and see up there, some good eats for lunch and dinner....so that isn't an issue. But the trip will be 2 1/2-3 hours each way. So if you leave at 7:00 AM you will be there by 10, leave at 7:00 PM back at 10. Definitely a full day affair.

That said, IF (big if) you can see and do what you want in NYC in the remaining time there AND (big and) it would be fun for both of you...I would say go for it.

If you have never been, you kind of have to at some point. I think there is a law or something.

Tom C
Reply With Quote