Quote:
Originally Posted by darkhorse9
Name the greatest player from each team that would never be in the discussion for the Hall Of Fame. They could be All-Stars, but never HOFers...Remember, if you could make a reasonable argument for them to get into the Hall they don't count.
|
Mark-
I would agree with most of your choices, but would say that
Alex Rodriguez will ALWAYS be in the Hall of Fame discussion. Whether he gets in or not is another topic, but he - like Pete Rose and others - will always be mentioned simply because of the amazing career he produced (albeit with help).
As a childhood White Sox fan, I’d choose Wilbur Wood over Dick Allen, and maybe make Allen a great choice for the Phils.
In addition to Crandall, a good choice for the Braves would be Ralph Garr.