Scott, is there any chance you can post some pics of the known repro's. Also wanted to add that I'm not too concerned about the monetary aspect of the piece other than if by chance it was cut out of a advertising piece I should take better care of it and not let the grand babies play with it
I'm just curious specially the crooked edges like it was cut out of something. Edited to add that when the stick is removed there is a printed portion of the original stick or holder part on the fan.