Quote:
Originally Posted by MW1
I would also add that perception is key here. Allowing the sale of cut-outs as a type of sports collectible opens the door to many items being termed legitimate, including pieces cut from pennants, logos cut from jerseys, etc.
If one third of a T202 or one half of a T201 isn't an authentic baseball card by itself, then how can a photo cut from a baseball guide be construed as a stand-alone collectible as legitimate as a baseball card?
I have no issue with ungraded pieces of paper exchanging hands for money, but when you see these same scraps, quite often with unrelated text on their reverses, selling $50, $100, or even more in holders where a 1 to 10 grade is assigned, you're implicitly telling the customer that they are receiving a sports collectible/card meant to be marketed as such. And the fact that a disclaimer even has to be attached to such an item should tell us something about what is being sold.
|
I am not really an "it opens the door" kind of guy on most things. I feel we should analyze things one at a time on their own merits.
We both agree on the grading of them. I have long argued against giving numeric grades to hand cut cards, especially with no caveat. I agree with you on that. However, as for the disclaimers they are there for a reason and can warn against danger. I like them on flips.