Quote:
Originally Posted by Bored5000
I am not trying to be a smart ass in any fashion, but where is the evidence to back up that claim? Is that just a made up claim pulled out of the air? 
People have cited hard numbers in this thread, and you argue that a team of Bretts would beat a team of Schmidts. Where is the "proof" or analysis of such a claim? That doesn't seem at all possible when Schmidt has superior numbers. The baseball-reference.com metrics take emotion out of the equation and say it is not real close between the two players. |
LOL Of course I pulled it out of the air.
This is fun and friendly banter, and we enjoy the sport. In our own minds we can justify why one player is better / the best than another. We look for different qualities and we are all correct in what we believe because of that.