I'm in complete agreement with you Jay, I didn't mean to suggest these two latest cards are to be considered OJs. I was careful to refer to the new players as merely adding to "Goodwin's photographic ensemble" and only really impacting the Cartophilic listing. I agree that a complete run of Old Judge subjects stands at 522 but the number of different subjects in the Cartophilic listing has now jumped to 524 IF we agree these were issued by Goodwin & Co. (which as previously stated I suspect is the case). There are now so many updates for the 2nd edition of the book
Very cool discovery, I love this stuff!