Hi Scot
E96
Perhaps, Philadelphia Caramel derived their info from Rossman's W600. Rossman's W600 cabinet (Circa 1904-06) identifies him with Cleveland.
The identical image of Rossman is depicted on the W600, T206, and E96 cards.
The American Caramel (E90-1) set has certain players in it whose careers ended several years prior to their issue date. Johnny Siegle comes
to mind....his career ended in 1906 (but his E90-1 card was issued in 1910).
My point here is.....that among some Candy issues similar discrepencies are found because the design (or planning) stage of certain subjects
preceded the actual issue date by as much as 2-4 years. I think I have noticed this also of some cards in the E91 set.
TED Z