It's called human beings. Card graders have to make these decisions all the time and while we used to make fun of people such as PRO for doing things like this, maybe in retrospect, they were ahead of their times.
Yes skinned Old Judges should be graded and notated as such as well. So should the 1984 Topps Nestle's cards of the full set which were professionaly cut back in the 1980's. Those are real cards and should be in holders.
As a matter of fact, the whole concept of "Sheet-Cut" cards needs to be changed at this point. If we've gone this far, why not allow for the OPC sheet cut hockey cards to be graded or anything else. Cards came from sheets, so grade em.
I think it can only help collectors long term
Rich
|