I haven't read through this entire thread, just the first couple of pages. However, personally, the cards were graded SGC 10/1, Poor. It is what it is, Poor, and I don't think that Legendary has any obligation to accept the return or provide recompensation. To me, this situation like someone buying a card off ebay, and then he tries to flip it, if he doesn't get the price he wants, he files a SNAD claim to return the card. I don't think that's right.
One thing about Legendary scans. I have noticed that Legendary and I'll bring up REA also, both of these notable auction houses have in general small scans for most of their listings, especially lotted listings. You cannot see most of the detail for the cards in their scans. In this day and age where some auction houses like Heritage and Huggins & Scott offer huge scans of the cards, both Legendary and REA are way behind the times. Both of these auction houses should offer much larger scans of all lots in their auctions than they currently do.
|