David,
You asked us to "humor" you, I tried doing that earlier in the thread, and the answer to the question is "its ass". My apologies for my poor attempt at humoring you....
These are SGC 10's ("1") so we would expect "issues". However, I understand where you're coming from because when I've sold cards on ebay I always tried to do my best to disclose issues on cards, even if they were graded a "1". Like someone mentioned much earlier in the thread, less fluff about the lot and more descriptive dialog should be used.
I'm not sure that it would have hurt the auction house to add a few more sentences, especially if they are going to make hundreds of dollars on the sale of the lot. We're talking about 5 minutes of time (to provide a more detailed description) and a few lines of text or making larger scans available. Hundreds of dollars of profit vs customer satisfaction?
As mentioned before, an email request for larger scans and/or a more detailed description of the lot could have prevented this.