It is Chick Evans with Boston NL. I wrote about it here (page 16):
https://sabr.box.com/shared/static/1...092a683653.pdf
BTW - that newsletter is (I think) a really good issue with respect to the subject of identifying faces. If you like this stuff please consider supporting SABR by joining.
RCMcKenzie - the Cleveland player on the OOTP site remains unidentified.