The SMR prices of Cracker Jacks are completely out of touch with reality. Obviously, some SMR price valuations are better than others. But SMR seems to be on another planet when it comes to Cracker Jacks, IMO.
I mostly look at the 1915 prices because that is more in line with my collecting budget. I have been wanting to pick up a lower grade Christy Mathewson and/or Grover Alexander for a while now. SMR shows the Matty at $215 in PSA1 and $390 in PSA2. Meanwhile, Alexander is shown at $65 in PSA1 and $110 in PSA2.
Even more ridiclous, SMR shows the 1915 Shoeless Joe at $1,150 in PSA1 and $1,950 in PSA2. Where are all these $1,150, or even $1,950, Joe Jackson Cracker Jacks being sold?