[buymycards]

Hi,
This is very interesting. Lew Lipsett lists the set as complete at 187 cards. SCD shows 188 cards. The difference is Demmitt. Lew shows him as Chicago American. SCD shows him as Chicago American with NY uniform and Chicago American with St Louis uniform.

The #1 set on the SGC registry is missing 5 cards:

Demmitt Chicago American NY uniform

Magee Philadelphia National - the #2 set has this card

McQuillan Phila Nat. - there is a mislabeled SGC slab on ebay - it is actually the Pittsburgh version.

Reulbach Brooklyn Fed

Sweeney Richmond

So, if the set only has 185 cards, 3 of the 4 cards listed above were never made - Demmitt, McQuillan, Reulback, or Sweeney. Does anyone have one of these cards? None of them are listed on ebay at the moment and I haven't checked the PSA registry.

Update - None of these cards are in the PSA set registry or pop reports. However, the SGC pop reports shows 1 Demmitt with NY uniform and 2 Sweeney Richmond.

That means 186 cards with 2 missing - Reulbach Brooklyn Fed. and McQuillan Phila. Nat. (If the pop reports are correct and no cards were incorrectly listed and graded.)


Rick