I'm not seeking witches, just the truth. eBay bidding aside, I'd like you all to take a second to visit
http://archive.org - if you've never been there, it's a great resource for many different things, including viewing old webpages.
On the first page type in the web address pastimebaseballs.com
You will see that it has crawled the site 6 times. If you view one of the views from 2010 or 2011 you will see the list of baseballs, etc they reproduce, etc.
Click on the 2013 portion of the timeline and it brings you up to date with what the site has been changed to - interesting.