Hilltop was on Broadway between 155th and 158th. The Old Put line was close by. Pretty clear at this point that the Old Put RR transported Highlander fans.
Does anyone out there have proof of a cigar brand named "Old Put"?
Seems like Old Put Cigar ephemera would be more common than the rare card stamp if they actually existed.
Seems to me that "Old Puff" would be a more likely name for a cigar.
But what do I know.
The map below shows the Old Put ending at 155th ST -- very interesting.