I agree with you, Jason, on the photo -- probably the cabinet.
And I also agree with you, Phil. These Johnson cards were clearly kept in print for many, many years in different iterations.
By the way, the Barr-Farnham cards were also issued in presentation albums, like the Goodwin link you posted, Jake. The interesting thing is that the ones in the albums all may not have been postcards, but real photos without the postcard back.
I have one that was actually a page from the album that was given to Jim Delehanty and it doesn't have the postcard paper backing. The stand-alone cards, of course, have been seen only with the real photo postcard paper backs.
Here's the Delahanty one:
The Barr-Farnham company also issued a 1909 postcard of the Baltimore Orioles. Here's the image from the Library of Congress:
