This list could not possibly satisfy everyone but it was extremely difficult to keep a top 10, especially being a Cubs fan. Here are my results and I am sad to say I only own 5 so I've got a very expensive journey ahead. Thank you all for your contributions to this thread and please keep showing your cards which is what it's all about.
No particular order:
1. Speaker - T205 / no secondary option at this time
2. Young - E90-1 / T205
3. WAJO - T206 / T204
4. Wagner - E90-2 / M116
5. Cobb - T206(green) / T205(Leon's)
6. Matty - T205 / E145
7. E. Collins - E104 / E90-1
8. Nap - T206 / E103
9. Plank - E95 / E107
10.Evers - E90-3 / E95
Lots of honorable mentions - E107 Joss, T205 Baker, M116(blue) Brown, E145 and T206 Tinker, E90-1 Bender, E95 Chance, E145 Mack and T204 Bender.
*List subject to change