Card number 1 in the '33 Goudey set is Benny Bengough. The Bengough card in that set definitely sells for more than you would think a Benny Bengough card would warrant, but $1,500 is high, IMO. SMR (I know, I know) lists the Bengough card as $600 in PSA5.
Card Target shows three sales last year of the card in PSA4 at an average of $277, and one sale last year in PSA5 at $900. The last PSA6 of that card (2010) listed on Card Target sold for $1,400.
http://www.cardtarget.com/cgi-bin/gm...submit=Display