I saved this image from
www.shorpy.com (highly recommended site if you're into black and white photography), and although it is neither my photo nor a HOFer, it fits the theme of the thread. Just love the contrast and composition of this image.
Washington, 1923. "Pillette of Detroit with Lincoln." Detroit Tigers pitcher Herman Polycarp Pillette. National Photo Co. glass negative
http://www.shorpy.com/node/4752 (Link has larger image with higher resolution)