I don't know for sure if the answers you got above or right, but I'm pretty sure they could tell just by looking at some cards through the holder, whether they think they are overgraded or not. We've seen plenty of cards posted here that are graded poorly. I have a PSA5 with paper loss on front(Old Judge card). If sure if I said don't grade it if it won't get a 5, they could tell right away it's not getting a 5 without taking it out.
Possibly, since you said it is a strip card, they may think it isn't big enough to grade. Since strip cards were hand cut, it's all very subjective anyway
|