Thanks Johnny, I always appreciate your kind words-thanks
I'm not trying to bash the card, or the opinions of the veteran collectors who have seen it in person- usually, these opinions would be my deciding factor being that it's the closest thing to seeing it in hand myself that I can get.
And, I'm not saying it's not legit. If it is, it is pretty groundbreaking. It would also be interesting to see the Brown Tolstoi that was mentioned. I haven't been collecting as long as many of you, but I guess the thing that keeps me on the fence is that with the signifigance of the Brown Old Mill I'd think it would've been announced as a new discovery awhile back? That's all.
If I knew I had this card in my collection I couldn't contain myself from announcing it to the hobby- but I am a T206 freak and it's only because I would love to own any only known example of a card
So I'll just say I'm confused.
Sincerely, Clayton