Hi Dan, First of all, how did the LaJoie get a PSA8 when it clearly has ink on the back. Shouldn't it have a qualifier?
http://www.goodwinandco.com/LotDetai...100&category=1
Second, I know I am in the minority, but given the paper stock that was used on the T206's I find it hard to believe that ANY T206's came off of the presses with the perfect cuts that are found on the 2 Goodwin cards. If by chance they did get perfect cuts, the chances of those perfect corners and perfect edges surviving intact for over 100 years seems impossible.
Compared to many others on the board my experience with T206's is limited, but I look at ALL PSA8's and above with deep suspicion.
Rick
Rick