| Archive |
09-08-2005 08:25 AM |
Regrade and Old Judge question
Posted By: <b>Bryan Long</b><p>I am going to put two questions in one to hopefully make things easier for everyone.<br /><br />1. Has anyone tried to the experiment to crack a card out of the holder and resend it back to the same company to get graded again and have a positive outcome? I have a nice looking SGC 20 that I think should be at least a 30. The card was graded quite some time ago and I was thinking about cracking it out and sending it in again. The card would bring at least a few hundred more if it came back a 30 instead of a 20. Has anyone done this a regular basis to give me an idea if the experiment is worth the risk?<br /><br />2. I am not an expert when it comes to Old Judge cards by any means. I know that trimmed and skinned old judge cards obviously command much less in price, but would a trimmed/skinned Browns Champion Commisky still sell for a few hundred dollars even in that condition? I'm not sure if that is rare card. I assume it is highly collected being Commisky from a subset of the old judge cards, but would it still command a decent price do you think? The reason I am asking this is that I have found a friend of a friend that has a few pre-war cards including this old judge, a mayo Duffy and pretty good shape and a few other cards and I am looking at a possible selling price that would be a decent deal for both of us. I'm not sure what else he has up to this point but I know that there is an e96 PSA 5 Mordecai Brown - but other than those three I'm not sure what else yet.<br /><br />Thanks in adavance for any help.
|
