Net54baseball.com Forums

Net54baseball.com Forums (http://www.net54baseball.com/index.php)
-   Net54baseball Vintage (WWII & Older) Baseball Cards & New Member Introductions (http://www.net54baseball.com/forumdisplay.php?f=2)
-   -   Uncut Sheet with 1951 Bowman Mickey Mantle RC in Collect Auctions (http://www.net54baseball.com/showthread.php?t=365979)

blades3 10-27-2025 01:40 PM

Uncut Sheet with 1951 Bowman Mickey Mantle RC in Collect Auctions
 
https://collectauctions.net/ItemImag...7321g_med.jpeg

A one-of-a-kind, once-in-a-lifetime Mickey Mantle Rookie card is in the national spotlight once again, this time in the hobby’s rarest format, a blazing 36-card uncut sheet that graces the marquee of the current Collect Auction’s sale that is online now. The 800-lot auction is found at collectauctions.net and closes on Nov. 6.

https://collectauctions.net/1951_Bow...-LOT61560.aspx

In yet another spectacular offering loaded with PSA-graded unopened packs from all sports and all eras, pristine unopened wax, cellos and vending boxes (many boasting the imprimatur of the fabled Larry Fritsch Card Company vault), autographed cards and sets, partial sets and PSA-slabbed panels from the famed Post Cereal baseball and football issues, a remarkable run of Exhibit cards dating back to 1921, Charles Fazzino hand-painted baseballs from Richard Nixon, Bruce Springsteen, George Steinbrenner & Jason Alexander, Tom Brady, Joe Montana and Brett Favre, and even a stunning dual-signed baseball featuring high-grade signatures of Babe Ruth and Mel Ott.

That’s an important sampling but it hardly exhausts the curriculum: the nicest 1964 Topps Baseball set we’ve ever handled, with almost 400 cards neatly ensconced in PSA 8 holders; autographs of everybody from Thurman Munson, Roberto Clemente, Mickey Mantle, Ted Williams, Joe DiMaggio, Willie Mays and Hank Aaron to even older guys like Humphrey Bogart, Charles Lindbergh, James Madison and James Monroe; there are pristine Hartland statues, including Ernie Banks with box and tag, plus an amazing run of PSA-graded beauties from famed 1952 Topps Baseball High Number Series, and, as they say, a whole lot more.

Still, with all that, we circle back to center stage and that awesome uncut sheet boasting the Mantle Rookie. Sheets are rare enough, especially from the classic early Bowman Baseball issues, and this one constitutes half of the difficult 72-card High-Number Series via cards numbered 253-288. The 18 ½ -by-12 ½-inch sheet is nothing short of sensational, with a lineup of three Hall of Famers (counting The Mick) and a host of important stars of the era. Joining Mantle’s fabled Rookie card are Hall of Famers Bucky Harris and Frankie Frisch, along with the likes of Danny Murtaugh, George Metkovich, Gene Bearden, Jackie Jensen, Birdie Tebbetts, Luke Easter, Chuck Dressen, Carl Erskine, Wally Moses, Gus Zernial, Howe Pollet and Don Mueller. Good company for the most treasured and important Rookie card of the postwar era.

View the whole auction at: https://collectauctions.net/catalog.aspx

Leon 10-27-2025 02:20 PM

That is a phenomenal sheet, Steve. Good luck with the auction and thanks again for letting Net54baseball help spread the word.
.

Zach Wheat 10-30-2025 11:58 AM

Simply amazing to see. Hope the auction goes well for all

GasHouseGang 10-30-2025 12:30 PM

Beautiful sheet. Probably the only thing that saved it from being cut up is the Mantle isn't perfect enough to try to cut out of the sheet and hope for an ultra high grade.

petecld 10-30-2025 02:25 PM

Sad...
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by GasHouseGang (Post 2547131)
Beautiful sheet. Probably the only thing that saved it from being cut up is the Mantle isn't perfect enough to try to cut out of the sheet and hope for an ultra high grade.


I think you are absolutely right and I think that is just sad. What a shame if that was cut up.

BillyCoxDodgers3B 10-30-2025 02:46 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by GasHouseGang (Post 2547131)
Beautiful sheet. Probably the only thing that saved it from being cut up is the Mantle isn't perfect enough to try to cut out of the sheet and hope for an ultra high grade.

Crumpled up Wagner strip redux (albeit so much nicer).

Beercan collector 10-30-2025 02:55 PM

I don’t think anyone would cut it up unless they think some of the commons will grade high - The reverse on the mantle has some surface wear that’s close to being paper loss. Currently at $54,000

Powell 11-08-2025 07:18 PM

Happy to win this item. I don’t think the 51 Mantle has received the credit it deserves as the true rookie.

Casey2296 11-08-2025 07:23 PM

Nice pick up Powell, congratulations.
I agree with you on the 51 Mantle, coupled with the 51 Mays they make a great pair.

Rhotchkiss 11-08-2025 09:43 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Powell (Post 2549047)
Happy to win this item. I don’t think the 51 Mantle has received the credit it deserves as the true rookie.

Really great pick up. Congrats

Powell 11-08-2025 10:05 PM

Thank you Ryan

GasHouseGang 11-09-2025 12:29 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Powell (Post 2549047)
Happy to win this item. I don’t think the 51 Mantle has received the credit it deserves as the true rookie.

Great sheet! Congrats on the pick up.

Arazi4442 11-09-2025 09:33 AM

Congratulations on the pick up. That’s a really great piece. How are you planning on displaying it?

calvindog 11-09-2025 09:44 AM

Such a great item.

Powell 11-09-2025 10:48 AM

Likely display it on a wall in my office which has all kinds of anti theft and fire protection

paul 11-09-2025 10:54 AM

Hopefully you have some sun protection too.

CW 11-09-2025 11:41 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Powell (Post 2549103)
Likely display it on a wall in my office which has all kinds of anti theft and fire protection

That's a museum worthy piece and congrats on adding it to your collection.

Just a suggestion, but you might consider asking the framer (should you choose to have it framed) to add rear mounting hardware that allows you to hang it either horizontally or vertically. It's always good to have options. :)

Powell 11-09-2025 12:35 PM

Great idea! Thank you

raulus 11-09-2025 12:44 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by paul (Post 2549104)
Hopefully you have some sun protection too.

Agree with this. I’ve had lots of art on the walls of my office that have faded dramatically over the years. In my case they were worthless bric-a-brac, so it didn’t matter so much.

JollyElm 11-09-2025 12:46 PM

1 Attachment(s)
There's only one place for it!!!

On your bedroom wall next to this...


Attachment 677058

MK 11-10-2025 04:45 PM

This same uncut sheet sold at the Copeland Auction in 1991 for $38,500. Lot #91 for anyone with the catalog.

iwantitiwinit 11-11-2025 03:21 PM

You 100 pct have to hang that vertically with Mick at the top!!

benjulmag 11-11-2025 05:45 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by MK (Post 2549346)
This same uncut sheet sold at the Copeland Auction in 1991 for $38,500. Lot #91 for anyone with the catalog.

As I recall, the one that sold at the Copeland auction was a different one, and I believe it was also a complete sheet.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 07:08 AM.