FS: 1887 N172 Old Judge HOF
 

I've decided to sell my 1887 Old Judge cards both cards are HOFers. I'm not sure what to offer for pricing since these are POP 1's but will take offers. I also have them listed on eBay as my seller's name is jackiemoonaba33.

Thanks
Bobby


Billy Hamilton - PSA 1 (POP 1) none higher **SOLD**
https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/...8a92682f_o.jpg

https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/...dce35470_o.jpg

Tommy McCarthy PSA 1MK (POP 1) with 2 higher
https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/...8a0c1a76_o.jpg

https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/...c186e6b8_o.jpg

FYI

SGC has graded 29 Hamiltons and 68 McCarthys

Plenty of comps out there.

Not sure how you came up with these number. I went on SGC website, and these were the results. There's been no sales on these cards since 2013 & 2017 in a PSA holder.

Hamilton POP 9 and only 1 with the card I have for sale. Hamilton has 6 variations.


McCarthy POP 20 and only 3 W/ St.Louis that I have for sale. McCarthy has 9 variations.

So what did Hamilton sell for

Why does it matter if it is a PSA sale vs SGC...especially in lower graded / altered cards?

SGC only recently started designating poses so specific pose pop #'s are meaningless.

Hamilton only has 5 poses (not 6) and none command a premium over any others.

I was giving you the benefit of the doubt that you were sincerely trying to find comps (vs trying to make these sound more special then they actually are) my mistake :)