Is this guy a Lookalike for someone else?
 

I cant believe this isnt Honus......
https://www.gradedcards.net/images/x1675.jpg Ive looked at other images of this guy and he sometimes looks a little like Wagner but usually not much at all. This image looks like Wagner to me .... what do you think?

I don't know about Wagner but he does look a bit like William Demarest, Uncle Charlie in 'My Three Sons'. Demarest was born in 1892 so I guess he could have been in the set if he played baseball.

Didn't this set duplicate the same images for multiple players? I know some of the sets of this timeframe just double and triple printed the images and put different player names under them each time.

The guy looks like a cross between Wagner and Cobb.