Which Would You Keep? Caramel Cobb Episode
 

I really like both of these...both very nice for their grade, imo. Which would you keep if you were looking to trade the other for a t206 cobb??

PSA without hesitation

I'm PSA on this one.

Psa, hands down!

I might keep the SGC and trade/sell the PSA. Most likely you will get more for the PSA version. Both present very well.

Keep the PSA

PSA for sure. That’s a fantastic 2.

I would keep the PSA...bolder color, sharper look.

Brian

I would keep the psa 2. I like the eye appeal of the psa 2 a bit better plus it looks nice in the new psa holder.

Both are really nice, but the PSA Cobb stands out. I say PSA

Psa 2 Pete.

Both amazing but agree on the psa.

PSA for sure, but both are beauties!

Bill

PSA..... I wish my poll on T205 Cobby's would have been clear cut.
.

i wish my e95 cobbs were as nice as your t205 cobbs?

I have a different approach. I agree, the PSA looks better, but if you like the SGC just as much, trade the one that presents better and get a better trade result. By the way, smart way to get eyes on your trade opportunity on the main forum. Sneaky.

PSA. I like the red background better and I do not like the corner on the SGC. They both are great cards though.

PSA, oh yeah.

I'm really split on this one. I've brought the thread up a few times and every time I look at the PSA example my eyes go straight to those 2 spots of paperless. To me they just stand out way too much. They are distracting. So while it has more issues, I'd lean toward the SGC as the flaws blend in better.

PSA without doubt!

Psa
 

Like Rich my initial reaction was ugh that paper loss really stands out and hurts the eye appeal. Then I saw the bottom left corner on the SGC and for me that hurts the eye appeal more! Really impressed with how well centered both examples are. Best of luck.