Opinions on Hafey and Paul Waner please
 

These have been part of my collection for 10+ years, not sure on these. Opinions very appreciated
Attachment 450494

Attachment 450495

Attachment 450496

Not a fan of the Waner. Looks like it's traced over but also some letter formations I don't like.

I dont care for the first Hafey or the Waner. The second Hafey is a maybe for me. A few things look off, but its close enough that it could be good.


Sent from my SM-G975U using Tapatalk

Agree that the first Hafey and the Waner are HIGHLY questionable. Both of those look terrible, IMHO.

Thanks everyone so far. The Waner originally I think came from a Clean Sweep auction with an old auction LOA from JSA if my memory serves me. No idea where I got the Hafeys and I agree. Was just hoping someone new of a variant signature that looked like one of these.
Any other opinions on batter up hafey???

I can't comment on the Hafeys. I bought a PSA/DNA Hafey 7 years ago. When I was looking I found multiple versions of his signature authenticated that were different. Some had quotation marks, some did not, others didn't look similar. I don't know why this is, but I wouldn't be too hasty to write them off until you get a quality opinion.

Sent from my SAMSUNG-SM-G930A using Tapatalk