Jimmie Foxx.. your favorite?
 

Am looking for ideas and suggestions on which Jimmie Foxx to add to my HOF collection - I look to have one card for every Hall of Famer and I’ve been debating which Foxx would be “the one“ for my collection.

My budget is around $500 and I am fine with lower to mid grade cards as long as they are decently centered. Probably like most collectors.

Would love to hear which Foxx you like best - thx for suggestions!

Jeff

I also have a HOF collection and here is the Foxx that I have for mine. I love the Kashin image as it was used for the 1933 Goudey card years later.

Nice card! Funny as a card friend just also suggested this one too...

I'll go with the vanilla, standard answer - the 1933 Goudey "rookie." Either number will do. I say, "rookie" because there is a debate.

However, I personally prefer the 1934 Goudey over the 1933. I like its design and colors more. Foxx is another underrated player - playing in the Babe and Lou's era overshadow his greatest.

Good luck.

I have the Delong Foxx. I'm not sure how much a lower grade one is selling for these days, but it may fit in your budget.

Love Foxx. There is a nice Batter Up Hi Number Foxx on ebay now, under $2.k, been tempted myself. Valuewise seems undervalued - but then that card does not sell at that price.

The postcard back exhibit rookie card would have fit the bill very nicely for you around the time that I stopped collecting the HOF rookie cards, around 2014. A nice mid-grade example could be had for around $500. Now, you can multiply that by ten, thus taking it out of range for most of us these days.

Maybe Leon could move this thread to the pre-war side where it belongs too.

For $500, you should be able to get a few options, unless you just want 1 nice example. I bought this Wheaties at auction for $50 18 months ago.

https://uploads.tapatalk-cdn.com/202...08ca8766a5.jpg

Sent from my SAMSUNG-SM-G930A using Tapatalk

Get the W560 if you can. It is one of the three considered a potential RC and it is way cheaper than the Exhibit. Or the Salutations Exhibit.

I would get either the 1933 Goudey or 1941 Play Ball. Those are his two nicest looking cards in my opinion.

I love the Dixie Lid Premiums. I think they are beautiful and under valued. You can get a nice Foxx for under $150.

https://www.ebay.com/itm/1938-Dixie-...-/264936956268

Probably should be on the prewar board.

I love the 1933 Goudey Foxx. Here's my example and I think it looks great for the grade. I also agree the 1941 is a nice example.


.

I picked this one up when it showed up on B/S/T.

Man, beautiful card! This may be “the one”

(Let me know if you want to unload this bad boy!)

Jeff, I'm like you. I was looking to purchase a nice Foxx and this is the one I decided to pick up.

This is my favorite:

Attachment 441469

No doubt! I LOVE this Foxx... the problem is that my budget does NOT love it as much as I do! (Have about $500 to buy my Foxx)

Thanks for all of the great suggestions, all.

I think I’ve decided to try and chase down a 34 Goudey - tough call but love the coloring plus I get a bonus of 2 HOFers on the front, in a way 😉

If anyone knows of anyone ready to move their 34 Foxxy, please let me know - thanks again all

Jeff

Too bad- it is available, but not for that price.