Centered?
 

First off, I'll say this is a really nice card. That being said, WTF constitutes for "centered" these days? I'm willing to give someone 60/40 even.......but this is a bit silly.

https://www.ebay.com/itm/T206-Cy-You...cAAOSw~LpcdCJx

I apologize if this is a board member's card. But I kind of doubt it, given the title.

that cy is NOT CENTERED!!!!!

Just keyword spamming given the craze. I am sure the seller knows it isn't centered.

With all the talk of PWCC's various letter codes, I think stuff like this is worse because the card just isn't centered. And it happens a lot, on eBay and elsewhere...

The card looks centered in the holder :D

yeah but it's harmless, everyone can see the centering
just sales talk

It's ALL really harmless sales talk, and while I don't shop PWCC stuff, especially the high priced stuff that gets letters added like it has a degree, I'm guessing at least those cards have a chance to live up to the hype. Describing a card like this as "centered" is just laughable, unless that adjective is preceded by "not."
If I'm in the market for a card, I might click on something that is described as "centered," but I pay no mind to any "X3JDKD" or whatever acronym a seller comes up with. I'd expect it be, you know, centered.

Yeah but you're not going to pay more for it because someone SAYS it's centered when it isn't. People clearly do pay more for stickered cards, on the other hand.

Yes on the first part. But do people pay more because the cards are stickered, or does PWCC do a good hob of identifying cards that are strong for the grade (thereby commanding a higher price)? I don’t think there’s evidence to prove which one is accurate.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Given the huge premiums I've seen, I would say at least in part it's the stickers. I've sold very high end for the grade cards on ebay and they don't do squat. And I've seen PWCC stickered cards that I felt were unworthy of any special sticker go very high.

Come on, guys, take it easy on the seller. He is clearly pointing to the fact that Cy Young himself is centered, you know, focused, intense. That's all it is. :cool:

I guess I’m not ready to claim causality, as there are other factors (including the number of people PWCC has in its network).


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

As opposed to Mark Fidrych, perhaps?


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Well you can't do a controlled study, so you can only go with what evidence is out there. I think it's pretty clear but in the end I couldn't prove it to you. But I am guessing the very reason Brent does it is because he too thinks it raises hammer prices.

The flip is well centered.

Does centered only count for left-to-right? Because I think the centering top-to-bottom is fairly nice. I would agree that there is vertical centering on this card.

A glass half full guy/girl right here, folks. Isn't it time for a well centered card to be shown?

It's the new E90-1 Young!! Great card, I've never understood why that issue, and the 4 on 1 Exhibits, get so little love.

What do you guys think about these two examples? As you can see, one has been deemed in the " top 15% " by a particular seller that is being discussed. I am actually inclined toward the other one. A little extra bottom border bothers me not.

https://uploads.tapatalk-cdn.com/201...49ae972e57.jpghttps://uploads.tapatalk-cdn.com/201...940f0b7175.jpg

Sent from my SM-G960U using Tapatalk

Centering isnt so black and white on tobacco/caramel sized issues imo. Some people prefer a larger lower border than others... as compared to even borders all around.

I was actually editing my post to say just that when you replied. I agree.

Sent from my SM-G960U using Tapatalk

👍🏿

I agree your example is dead center, or even as you say well centered. The title doesn't say dead centered, it just says centered, and in the context of centered top/ bottom the seller isn't lying. Now if the picture was completely shoved into one corner, there would neither be centering top/ bottom, nor left/ right. And that would be a lie. Would this example receive a qualifying mark of OC? Yes, because that's undeniable. Is the seller being deceptive, that's debatable; it's allowing him to hit more tags and I don't see anything wrong with that. The seller is trying to get as many views as possible. Hopefully buyers preview pictures before purchasing.

Sent from my SAMSUNG-SM-G930A using Tapatalk

It gets your desired effect but irks me because the card isn't centered. lt is more like off centered. If it said half centered then I would be ok with it. :cool:

I look at it like this: I want to buy Tris Speaker cards. I have many examples before me, and I want to get the best one that I can afford. There is horizontal centering, and vertical centering. If I have the money, I will ignore cards that are off centered in both categories. Then I am left with options that are centered one way, but not the other. But I do like your term half centered.

My dad was in sales, and it was always about closing the deal. If this seller needs to say centered to close the deal, than do it.

Sent from my SAMSUNG-SM-G930A using Tapatalk

I agree it is good to close the sale. But it is better to close the sale and form long relationships based on reality and trust. Before I got this gig I was in outside IT sales for a little over 20 yrs, straight commission. If I misled my customers they wouldn't have come back to me. I had several customers for close to 20 yrs when I got out of the industry. But to each their own I guess. Descriptions can still irk me though :).
Here is one, shown many times, that is well centered but I doubt I would call it perfectly centered.
ps...on the 2 Chases, above, even though I like those big bottom borders I like the other one a little better. There is no right or wrong answer on that one.
l

Anyone can tell if a card is centered or not. Lying about something obvious is not salesmanship in my opinion. If someone can't be honest about what is clearly visible in a scan what else will they lie about? I would avoid a seller like this.

I don't avoid them altogether., As long as they have good pics it isn't a big deal. I's fun to lament about it. Here is a group of fairly well centered W575-1s that came out of a pack.