Rookie purchase. Stargell, bench, Robinson...
 

I was looking to get a PSA 6-7 Stargell, Robinson, Bench,
Carlton, Morgan. I can only afford one and was wondering if anyone had an opinion on which card they thought the best value. Especially regarding scarcity and cost. Thanks!

I'm not an expert but I'm guessing scarcity wise the Stargell would fit the bill since it's a high number in the 63 set. Though a lot of people don't like the quad floating heads. Robinson I'm assuming Frank. He is a very affordable guy to collect in this hobby and he has his own card versus the rest on this list. My favorite in this group is the Bench. Love the look of that card. Good luck.

Thank you :) Im a pirate fan so was leaning that way. However if one of the others is that much better of an option I would certainly consider it.

As Stephen said, it's a high number, so that works in your favor. The big 'problem' is, Pops' cards don't really have any of the glamour of other main HOF'ers. It's sad in a way, but he's ignored a lot by collectors. People are always looking for Mays, Mantle, Aaron, Ryan, etc., from that era, but Willie has been a secondary concern. There isn't a premium paid for his cards. If you're looking purely for investment, I'd say grab a nice Bench. Although not really rare, that card seemingly has staying power.

Welcome to the boards "Slick"!

Haha, thank you!